in keeping with its annual tradition, is pleased to present to its readers the much-anticipated list of 100 important Supreme Court judgments from the current year. This curated collection serves as a valuable resource for legal practitioners, judges, and students alike. The selection process is meticulous, guided by three key criteria: (i) significance to the general public, (ii) resolution of contested legal positions, and (iii) practical utility for those actively engaged in the legal profession.
This yearly compilation is more than just a list; it's a comprehensive guide to the legal landscape, offering insights into pivotal decisions that have shaped the jurisprudential framework of the country. The chosen judgments reflect not only their legal importance but also their broader impact on society.
The first criterion, importance to the general public, underscores the social relevance of the judgments. The Supreme Court often grapples with cases that have far-reaching implications for citizens. These cases could involve fundamental rights, constitutional principles, or matters of public interest. By including judgments that meet this criterion, LiveLaw ensures that its list resonates with a broad audience, transcending the legal community to reach the general public.
The second criterion, settlement of a contested position of law, speaks to the Court's role in providing clarity and guidance on legal issues. Legal practitioners often encounter ambiguities or conflicting interpretations of the law. The Supreme Court, in its decisions, serves as the final arbiter, bringing resolution to these contested positions. LiveLaw's selection recognizes the significance of these judgments in establishing legal precedents and promoting a more cohesive and predictable legal system.
The third criterion focuses on the practical utility of the judgments for lawyers, judges, and students. Legal professionals, in their day-to-day practice, seek guidance from precedent-setting decisions. These judgments become tools for argumentation, interpretation, and application. By including judgments that are particularly useful for the legal community, LiveLaw ensures that its list goes beyond academic interest, providing a valuable resource for those actively involved in the field.
It is essential to note that LiveLaw includes a disclaimer, acknowledging the subjective nature of the selection process. The disclaimer emphasizes that the list does not claim to be exhaustive or infallible. Instead, it serves as a curated compilation based on the mentioned criteria. This transparency adds a layer of accountability to the process, acknowledging the inherent challenges in objectively evaluating the significance of legal decisions.
In conclusion, LiveLaw's annual compilation of 100 important Supreme Court judgments is a testament to the dynamic and evolving nature of the legal landscape. It serves as a snapshot of the legal year, capturing the most impactful decisions that have shaped the course of law in the country. As a comprehensive resource, it not only benefits legal professionals but also contributes to the broader understanding of the role of the judiciary in shaping society.
TAGS: Supreme Court 2023 Top 100 Judgments Part 3 Legal Decisions Case Law Judicial Rulings Legal Landscape Jurisprudence.
