On September 5, 2024, the Allahabad Tall Court, Lucknow Seat, rejected a appeal recorded by Daya Shanker Pathak beneath Article 227 of the Structure, looking for an sped up choice on a case pending some time recently the Uttar Pradesh Open Benefit Tribunal. The applicant had drawn closer the court looking for quick transfer of his case, which related to a punishment arrange issued in 2022. In any case, the court found no compelling reason to meddled and rejected the request as without justify.
Background
The solicitor, Daya Shanker Pathak, recorded a summons request beneath Article 227 of the Structure of India, asking the Tall Court to coordinate the Uttar Pradesh Open Benefit Tribunal to speed up the choice in his case. His case, recorded some time recently the tribunal in 2022, challenged a punishment arrange forced by the specialists. The solicitor contended that the delay in choosing the matter was unjustified and asked the court to intercede for faster determination.
Court’s Observations
Justice Subhash Vidyarthi presided over the matter and provided a detailed examination of the issues raised by the petitioner. The court observed that while the petitioner sought to expedite administrative processes, there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that the state authorities had acted unlawfully or had intentionally caused delays.
Judgment
The petition was dismissed by the Allahabad High Court on the grounds that it was without merit. It was declared by the court that "the petition is without substance and stands dismissed." Justice Vidyarthi's ruling further clarified that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate any clear legal violation by the state that warranted court intervention.
Conclusion
This case underscores the principle that higher courts are generally reluctant to interfere with administrative proceedings unless there is concrete evidence of misconduct or intentional delays. The Allahabad High Court’s decision reflects its commitment to ensuring that judicial resources are applied only in cases where there is a clear violation of legal or constitutional rights.
Click Here to: Download/View Related File
TAGS: Allahabad High Court Rajendra Singh State of Uttar Pradesh Article 227 administrative delays statutory duties judicial intervention court ruling case dismissal
